Rubber Plantation in Northeast India, hopes vs. concerns

Jan 21 2012

By Achintya Kumar Sinha, IFS (Retd.)

Rubber, a major plantation crop in northeast India, had a quiet entry to this verdant land with the first plantation raised in Tripura in 1963 by Naresh Bhattacharjee, the venerable Forest Chief of the territory. Bhattacharjee had become a legend of sorts and stories grew around him. The one in this context goes like this. He believed that commercial success of rubber plantation in Kerala could be replicated in Tripura. Bhattacharjee advised the Rubber Board accordingly but the Board officials argued against citing the harsh winter and protracted dry season in Tripura. A seasoned forester known for his down-to-earth wisdom and tenacity, Bhattacharjee did not relent. He planted rubber in degraded forestland under a soil conservation scheme and monitored in person every aspect of its management, as if to prove a point. In a queer coincidence, the Soil Conservation Department of undivided Assam had also raised rubber plantations in a few locations soon thereafter, but it was in Tripura that its enormous potential was promptly relaised and pursued. Bhattacharjee's healthy crop of rubber seized soon enough the attention of the Rubber Board, which opened in 1967 its first office in the northeast at Agartala.

Another high point in this rubber story came about in 1976 with the establishment of Tripura Forest Development & Plantation Corporation Limited. The corporation adopted rehabilitation of degraded forestland through rubber plantation as a principal strategy and took up simultaneously a project to wean away a cluster of tribal families of Warangbari village of West Tripura from shifting cultivation by providing wage employment through rubber plantation. Soon after the site clearance had began, the Warangbari community got wary of permanent loss of land for shifting cultivation and an array of other livelihood necessities that the land delivered. On the face of a determined protest en masse, the corporation officials parleyed with the Warangbari villagers, who agreed to allow rubber plantation on condition that those would be allotted to them on maturity. It was amazing that the state government actually accepted the rather unusual demand. The families thus worked on daily wages under the corporation for establishment of rubber plantations in government land which would be allotted to them on maturity.

The Warangbari experience was the precursor to establishment in 1983 of a separate agency, Tripura Rehabilitation Plantation Corporation Limited, solely for economic rehabilitation of marginalised tribal families on rubber plantations. The same model was adopted mutatis mutandis in Tripura by the RD and Tribal Welfare Departments, Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council as well as the Rubber Board in its high profile Block Plantation Scheme launched for the northeast in 1992 but implemented so far only in Tripura. Around 22,000 marginalised tribal families in Tripura benefitted from the aforesaid rehabilitation packages till 2008-09. Beneficiaries earn a handsome income from sale of latex (May, 2011 price of sheet rubber is around Rs.220/- per kg) from mature plantations, which on average produce around 1300 kilograms of natural rubber per ha. The Rubber Board is now firmly entrenched in the northeast excluding Sikkim, considered unsuitable for rubber plantation. The area under rubber and production of natural rubber in the northeast in 2008-09 were 88,865 ha and 37,240 tonnes respectively as against 36,285 ha and 19,420 tonnes for the rest of the non-traditional region comprising of Karnataka, Goa, Maharashtra, Orissa, West Bengal, Andhrapradesh and Chhattisgarh. The 11th Plan target for the northeast was set at 25,000 ha against 2,500 ha for the rest of the non-traditional region; and share of the target for Tripura alone was 12,400 ha. The advent of rubber set off a stunning transformation in the landscape and rural economy in Tripura pioneering in a way the emergence of the northeast as the principal rubber growing region in the country outside the traditional belt. The potential area (National Bureau of Soil Survey and Land use Planning) identified for rubber in the northeast is 4,50,000 ha against the actual area of 5,36,830 ha (2008-09) in the traditional region comprising of Kerala and Kanyakumari district of Tamilnadu. Bhattacharjee, the indomitable Forest Chief of Tripura, did indeed prove his point.

It would be fair at this stage to clarify that the Rubber Board officiials were technically correct in case they really had discouraged commercial cultivation of rubber in Tripura initially. Desired locality factors within the tropics for commercial cultivation of rubber are gently undulating topography with slope between 5 degrees to 15 degrees, well-distributed high rainfall and humidity; no pronounced droughts; winter, if at all, to be mild and short; and no prolonged seasonal winds, storms or cyclones. Evidently, the northeast did not fit the bill ideally. The fact that the country needed more natural rubber - a strategic raw material - to prop up its industrial growth was obviously of paramount importance. India emerged as the second largest consumer of natural rubber next to China since 2009 (in thousand tonnes: China- 3467; USA- 687 & India- 905); and it simultaneously became a net importer (1,28,000 tonnes) for the first time there since then. There was minimal scope for further growth in the traditional rubber belt and the rest of the non-traditional region; the focus as a result was on the newfound northeast.

Fortunately, rubber is fairly adaptable to some deviations from the ideal climatic requirements albeit with consequent impact on growth and productivity. Such adverse impacts to an extent can be moderated through management interventions; but it will be prudent to accept that overall performance of rubber in the northeast cannot match that of the traditional belt. The average productivity of rubber plantation in India is around 1800 kilograms per ha. The traditional belt, which accounted for 93% of production and 81% of area coverage (2008-09), largely influence the national average productivity. As against that the production in Tripura in 2010-11 was 1456 kilograms per ha (Total plantation: 53039 ha; mature plantation: 24520 ha; production: 35693 tonnes).

The national authorities adopted the agenda to double the area under rubber in the northeast over a period of ten years since 2007-08. There is no quarrel with the programme that aims at meeting the rising demand of a strategic raw material like natural rubber for industrial growth in the country. There is, however, need for caution lest there be blunders in this mad rush. The areas of concern are many; and the first and foremost is on the general preparedness in the northeast for this gigantic leap. The present administrative and extension network of the Rubber Board in the northeast under one zonal office for Tripura and another for the rest of the region for issue of permit, release of subsidy, training and technical guidance, insurance, etcetera is grossly inadequate.

Availability of genuine planting material of recommended cultivars is far too short vis-à-vis the demand. The market is flooded with spurious saplings which account for bulk of the planting material used by private growers oblivious of the disastrous implications. Neither the Rubber Board nor the government departments and organizations engazed in the rubber sector in the northeast have adequate nursery infrastructure to support the massive planting programme. To add to the malady, the Rubber Board discontinued regulation, including inspection and registration, of private rubber nurseries since 1986.

Rubber is grown in the northeast in uplands degraded and impoverished as a result of shifting cultivation. A generous input of fertilizer is therefore essential for its commercial viability. The requirement of fertliser is between 400 to 500 kilograms per ha per annum both for immature and mature plantations. Shortage of fertilizer has even otherwise been a perennial problem in the northeast due to unreliable communication links, inadequate storage facilities and inefficient distribution network; and with the priority that agriculture enjoys, rubber ends up as the worst victim.

Almost the entire rubber latex in the northeast is processed in to sheets for sale as a large majority of the plantations are in small holdings. About four cubic meters of fuel wood is burnt to produce one tonne of dry and smoked rubber sheets. Use of biogas in addition from latex processing facilities to reduce fuel wood consumption for the purpose, though introduced by the Rubber Board in a few centres, were almost totally ignored due to lack of confidence or awareness, high cost of installation, absence of local implementing agencies and reliable post-installation services. In Tripura alone a stock of wood corresponding to around 1000 ha of forestland would have been burnt to process 35693 tonnes of rubber produced during 2010-11. Vast tracts of the countryside in certain parts of Tripura are almost devoid of any tree other than rubber. Tripura forests too are under heightened stress.

While most rubber planters might sound happy with the handsome returns from their plantations in Tripura, their women folks often express their desperation in missing the bamboo shoots, delicious wild vegetables, tuber crops and medicinal herbs delivered by the erstwhile natural vegetation. Tripura witnessed an extra-ordinary expansion of rubber plantation in recent times (2005-06:- 31673 ha & 2010-11:- 53039 ha); and many in the villages and the civil society now blame the large-scale substitution of indigenous vegetation by rubber for the drying hill streams and village wells. They express concern about the foul-smelling effluent from rubber sheet processing units that pollute the soil, water and the air they are to live on. Remedial measures are often listed but hardly ever put in place and practiced. These concerns, real without a doubt, will grow in enormity with time and there is seemingly no serious action plan or endeavor in sight for remedies.
It is appropriate under the circumstances to explore, identify and implement alternative farming models for commercial rubber cultivation in the northeast that meet the livelihood needs and other aspirations of the ethnic communities, who depend a lot more on the land with its indigenous biodiversity, compared to those in the traditional rubber belt in Kerala. There is an urgent need for dedicated trial in the northeast to promote rubber in pure blocks of one acre or more separated by blocks of existing natural vegetation or new plantations of trees bearing edibles and trees for other utilities chosen by the local communities. The farmers should be encouraged for intercropping under immature rubber plantations with tuber crops, legumes, etcetera to ensure food security and income during the long gestation period by linking subsidy to compliance of this planting model.

It is time one appreciates the reality that rubber, despite its apparent acceptance in the northeast, is not a natural choice. It is essentially a subsidy driven programme to meet a national objective that also helps the northeast. There have been other developments in respect of other plant resources. Technology for new generation value-added products from bamboo with a rapidly growing export market has put this tall grass in the center-stage for industrial development in the northeast, home to two thirds of the growing stock of bamboo in India. Economic growth based on bamboo will suit the social and cultural milieu and will be a prudent option for the ecologically fragile region. There would be other worthy farming and non-farming options suited to this region; and to write them off in favour of the alien rubber would be irrational.

In fine, there remains, with due regards to the great potential of rubber, a strong case for drawing up an inclusive futuristic land use plan for horticulture and plantation crops in the northeast by an expert group constituted by the NEC with members from the ICAR, Indian Council of Forestry Research and Education, the Rubber Board, National Bamboo Mission, National Medicinal Plants Board and the Spices Board. Meanwhile, the present target for ten years for creation of rubber plantation in the northeast may be downsized right away by the Rubber Board in view of the constraints illustrated and to explore alternatives for optimal utilisation of uplands in the northeast for sustainable benefit.

State wise area under rubber in the northeast as in 2008-09 (Source: The Rubber Board):


State

Geog. area (km2)

Area suitable for rubber (ha)

Area planted (ha)

Arunachal Pradesh

83743

25,000

720

Assam

78438

200,000

23705

Manipur

22327

10,000

2380

Meghalaya

22429

50,000

7740

Mizoram

22081

50,000

735

Nagaland

16579

15,000

3515

Sikkim

7096

0

0

Tripura

10486

100,000

50070

Total

263179

450,000

88865


The author can be reached at achintyaksinha@gmail.com

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Feel free to visit my webpage - Frederick

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Of course, buy the food you normally eat, and supplement
the larder with comfort foods as you like.

My web-site; cheapest emergency food supply (Mei)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Personal prepping can also be a state of emotion; what your personal personal
emergency is would possibly decide how a lot you possibly can make
investments into prepping not essentially on a monetary foundation, but on an emotional foundation as effectively.

My web site; free emergency food - Lily,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Now go and start prepping the fitting means for
your loved ones's subsequent trip to the playground!

Here is my weblog - pre made survival kits - www.jp-sunika.com,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You can get lost in the woods even if you have been to the area before.

Here is my web page: rational.com (Madie)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Keep the environment in thoughts if you find yourself at your
campsite.

My weblog building a survival kit (Epifania)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Collectively, the authors cover each catastrophe that comes to thoughts when discussing the "massive dangerous." Maybe this reader's favourite side of this ebook: The authors
concentrate on the layman's preparation for catastrophe, asking the query
"what are you trying to survive?" I discovered this to be a refreshing strategy—difficult not only those that view prepping as weird,
but those who take prepping to overzealous levels.

Here is my weblog ... emergency survival kit contents
[Otto]

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Excellent post. Keep writing such kind of info on your page.
Im really impressed by your site.
Hey there, You have done a great job. I will certainly digg it and
personally recommend to my friends. I am sure they'll be benefited from this website.

Feel free to visit my website killer deal (3alleedu8mai.free.fr)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a coworker who had been doing a little homework on this.

And he actually ordered me dinner because I discovered it for
him... lol. So allow me to reword this.... Thank
YOU for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending time to talk about this subject here on your internet site.

Also visit my webpage ... Best Injury Lawyer Whites Creek TN

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You can find everything from posters to panties saying 'Team Edward' or 'Team Jacob' on it.
Supreme Court, but not everything that is protected by the First
Amendment right to free speech is equally laudable.
You will be surprised to know that the gaming consoles are not only popular among kids, but adults are also in love with playing video games.

my web-site :: mon site (http://www.eruuludam.mn)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

This article will focus on some wonderful tips that can make your next camping trip
a success!

Here is my weblog: mountain house food - Lizette -

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You don't have tto any concern your self with not working Fallout Shelter Hacks
that iis have anywhere.

Here is my web site ... Fallout Shelter Hack

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

If you need to leave for any reason, make sure the campfire is extinguished completely.

Here is my web blog; bug out bag equipment; Orville,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Your survival kit can be the difference between you making it out of the woods on a stretcher or your own two feet.

Also visit my site; sale kits

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Here is my webpage - Lorene

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You don't need to be caught setting up camp after
darkish, so simply arrive slightly earlier than you normally would.

My blog post: multi survival tool (http://facefarsi.xzn.ir/Rolando452)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

What's up colleagues, its wonderful paragraph concerning cultureand fully explained, keep it up all the time.

Also visit my web-site - downfall of tanning

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Reserves of gold are nonetheless held by some nations
as gold bullion coins, for instance the Australian Gold Nugget, or the British Britannia.

My web page ... Gertie

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

This is the right blog for everyone who really wants to understand this topic.
You know a whole lot its almost hard to argue with
you (not that I actually will need to…HaHa). You certainly put a brand new spin on a
subject that has been discussed for many years.
Wonderful stuff, just wonderful!

my homepage :: Infinite No2

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Superb blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
I'm planning to start my own site soon but I'm a little lost on everything.

Would you suggest starting with a free platform
like Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out
there that I'm completely confused .. Any suggestions? Bless you!

Also visit my web site: www.smokylok.com

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

To prepare the surface that is going to be painted, you have to use soap and
water, scrapers, brush or sandpaper in order to
remove old paint flakes.

Feel free to surf to my page ... impossible survival stories

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Pitch the tent in an already familiar space, and let him sleep or play in it
for some time. Bringing a dog can actually add to
the fun of tenting, as long as the animal has
been adequately ready for the event.

My web blog - survival tents for sale (Dora)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Recreation οf warfare fireplace age cheat ϲomes гeally helpful since
many video games ɑг&#6513 actually exhausting гight thіѕ second.

Feel fee t&#1086 surf tо mʏ webpage: game &#11423f wɑr fire age hack apk no survey (Http://Gameofwarhack.Over-Blog.com/)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Food will be bought up and desperation among the people will cause
panic, theft and vandalism.

my blog post survival kit for kids (Luke)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Food- while storing food now is great; you need to look toward the future
once all hell breaks loose you will not be stocking
up at Costco anymore!

my homepage ... emergency survival foods;
Consuelo,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

The APN exists to help people learn about Prepping and to facilitate
them becoming Self Reliant through increased personal responsibility.

Have a look at my page ... buy survival kit (Anderson)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hurrah! Finally I got a website from where I can truly take useful facts concerning my study and knowledge.

My web page leadership potential

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Very soon this website will be famous amid all blogging and site-building people, due
to it's nice articles
Chelsea

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Usually I don't learn post on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very pressured
me to take a look at and do so! Your writing style has been surprised me.
Thank you, very great post.

my web-site :: TNS Essential Serum Skincare

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Ensure you at all times have a supply of clean water with you.

Feel free to surf to my weblog gourmet snacks online
- Nelly,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Anyone with 2 machines will certainly mmore than likely tell you
what is the best bread machine (shockingband8968.shutterfly.com) much more expensive design makes better bread.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You'll just end up paying for it later... and at
that point, you may be paying much more than you would have if you'd simply
taken a pragmatic approach to paint pretreatment at the beginning.

Visit my homepage - emergency survival food supply, Sammy,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

But in addition to its use as a game, it is also a great way to
strengthen a paper plate.

Also visit my web site ... diced ham (Brianna)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Right here is the right web site for everyone who would like to understand this topic.

You realize a whole lot its almost tough to argue with you (not
that I really would want to…HaHa). You certainly put a new spin on a topic that has been written about for
many years. Great stuff, just great!

My site ... Neuroplex Pro

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading?
I'm trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog.
Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

Look into my webpage Age Rewind Side Effects

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

WOW just what I was searching for. Came here by searching for loss
diet

Review my weblog; http://www2.tku.edu.tw

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You could also read about different first aid techniques online.

Feel free to surf to my homepage ... best bag
for a bug out bag (Madelaine)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

My page; Grazyna

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hello mates, pleasant article and nice arguments commented at
this place, I am genuinely enjoying by these.

my web blog :: Ultimate Home Profits Reviews

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

School lunchroom workers say that kids throw away a great deal of the food sent with them.

Review my web site ... guardian survival, Shannon,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your weblog and in accession capital to assert
that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I
will be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement
you access consistently rapidly.

Visit my website; Ian Leaf

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Throughout massive flooding like Hurricane Katrina residents discovered themselves residing on the
second floor or the roof with no entry to food or provides.

Also visit my website :: hunters survival kit (Eliza)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You made some really good points there. I checked on the web to learn more about
the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this website.

my page - antiques houston

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Magnificent goods from you, man. I've understand your stuff previous to and
you're simply too magnificent. I actually like what you've obtained here, certainly like what you're saying and the way in which you are saying it.
You are making it enjoyable and you continue to take care of to
keep it smart. I cant wait to read much more from you.
This is really a great site.

Check out my web page :: onzdradza.pl (Marissa)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Whereas there are many definitions of what prepping means,
the essential view is that of an individual or group that prepares to fulfill the challenges of survival in a self-reliant manner when society and life-style as we presently know them are paused or redefined.

Here is my web blog: 4 in 1 bucket for sale (Shawna)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Charley Hogwood's book MAGS, the people part of prepping ; finally breaks the mold.

my homepage :: emergency kit for hurricane, Darcy,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hi there mates, its impressive article concerning tutoringand completely defined, keep
it up all the time.

Also visit my web blog: www.christapostolicchurchmom.org

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Appreciation to my father who shared with me concerning this webpage, this blog is genuinely amazing.

Feel free to visit my web page; perfect biotics

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Link exchange is nothing else but it is only placing the other person's weblog link on your
page at appropriate place and other person will also do same in support of
you.

Look into my homepage ... Check This Site For The Latest In Furniture